This week, the Federation of American Hospitals submitted a letter to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS) with detailed, comprehensive comments on the Medicaid Managed Care proposed rule. The purpose of the proposed rule is to modernize existing regulations to reflect the changes that have occurred in Medicaid and the managed care marketplace. The FAH letter praises the direction in which certain provisions in the proposed rule are headed, and urges CMS to consider adjustments to strengthen many of the provisions.
As detailed in the letter, the FAH analyzes the direction and implementation of various provisions proposed by CMS:
Payment for Institution for Mental Disease Services
The FAH supports the direction of the Agency’s proposal to permit Medicaid managed care organizations (MCOs) to cover short-term inpatient care for enrollees in an institution for mental disease, but the proposed 15 day per month per enrollee cap on coverage is unnecessary, arbitrary, and arguably inconsistent with parity as there is no similar limit on medical and surgical services. If CMS imposes a cap, we recommend a facility-specific average of 25 days.
Network Adequacy
The FAH supports the requirement of states to develop and enforce network adequacy standards. The FAH urges CMS to adopt and adapt the Medicare Advantage standards for use with the Medicaid managed care population for like conditions, or another set of standards that provide a quantitative minimum threshold to serve as a floor for State-based standards upon which desiring States may add additional requirements. The standards also should include provisions to guard against “phantom” networks, in which plans appear to have a full network on paper, but because of closed panels or other factors, Medicaid recipients are unable to access the network as defined.
Medical Loss Ratio
The FAH commends CMS for proposing medical loss ratio (MLR) requirements for MCOs, and we believe the proposal is a significant step in the right direction. The FAH urges CMS to strengthen the proposed MLR requirements by:
- -Requiring States to apply an enforcement mechanism when MCOs fail to comply with the 85 percent minimum MLR threshold, along with penalties for repeat offenders;
- -Requiring federal audits of MLR submissions; and,
- -Not including fraud prevention activities in the MLR numerator.
Actuarial Soundness
The FAH appreciates CMS’s effort in the proposed rule to ensure that States meet specific requirements to establish actuarially sound rates, and commends CMS for its proposal to mandate that States post or otherwise make publicly available MCO contracts and various pieces of data relevant to actuarial soundness determinations, the MLR calculation, and the adequacy of the plan’s provider network. This is crucial information for providers and the public.
State Rate Setting Within Managed Care
The FAH urges that, when a State establishes rates for certain services or providers, CMS require the State to apply existing Medicaid FFS law in the managed care context. Under this scenario, States would provide the methods and procedures related to rates that the State mandates that a MCO pay to a provider, and CMS would review these payment methods, procedures and rates to ensure they are consistent with efficiency, economy, and quality of care, and are sufficient to enlist an adequate number of providers in the network.
Supplemental Payments and Medicaid Managed Care
The FAH urges CMS to eliminate the “direct pay” prohibition, which prohibits states from making direct payments for services provided to beneficiaries in Medicaid managed care. Alternatively, CMS should amend its regulations to accommodate State programs that provide supplemental payments to offset the payment shortfalls experienced by providers caring for Medicaid beneficiaries.
Prompt Payment for Non-Contracted Provider Services
CMS also should work to establish minimum prompt payment standards for services by non-contracted providers no less than that required of MA organizations.
Coverage of Emergency Services for Non-Contracted Providers
The FAH urges CMS to adopt Medicaid FFS payments as a floor for MCOs with regard to payment for emergency services, including admissions resulting from emergencies, for non-contracted providers, and this policy should also apply to post-stabilization care services.
Protection of Emergency Care for Enrollees
We support CMS’s efforts in the proposed rule to ensure that MCOs cover and pay for emergency services and certain post-stabilization care services, including defining “emergency medical condition” using a “prudent layperson” standard. Under current law and the proposals in the rule, MCOs could not inappropriately deny or limit coverage and payment for emergency services, including making payment only for triage services, downcoding claims for emergency care and services, or engaging in other similar forms of reducing coverage and payment for these services. To ensure proper payment for these services, we urge CMS to reiterate expressly, in the final rule, that MCO payment and coverage of EMTALA-mandated services are required, including:
- -All services and supplies medically necessary to adequately screen, stabilize, and treat a patient, including post-stabilization care; and,
- -Emergency services and care, including all stabilization and treatment services, including all screenings, evaluations and examinations that are reasonably calculated to assist the provider in determining whether the enrollee has an emergency medical condition, even if an emergency medical condition is later determined not to have existed.
Program Integrity & Recovery of Overpayments to Network Providers
The FAH urges CMS to adopt and adapt the Medicare Advantage approach for the recovery of overpayments to network providers, which does not impose a mandatory 60-day requirement and allows plan-provider issues to be resolved through contractual terms.
Tracking System for Grievances and Appeals
The FAH supports a requirement to use an online system to track the status of grievances and appeals to help ensure accountability by Medicaid managed care plans. However, the FAH urges CMS to clarify that the grievance and appeals processes, like the MA grievance and appeal processes, only apply to providers that do not have a written contract with a MCO.
The FAH supports the efforts of CMS to update these critical Medicaid managed care health care delivery systems. It is imperative that programs evolve along with major transformations in our industry. The FAH is proud to submit feedback on the proposed rule, and looks forward to working with CMS to improve the Medicaid managed care program.