On Monday, Health Affairs published a new report co-authored by FAH President & CEO Chip Kahn titled, Assessing Medicare’s Hospital Pay-for-Performance Programs and Whether They Are Achieving Their Goals. The study examines the impact of three key Medicare pay-for-performance programs: Value-based Purchasing (VBP), the Hospital-Acquired Conditions (HAC) Reduction Program and the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program. This week, the study has gained media attention from several leading media outlets.
The study was highlighted by POLITICO Pulse, and included extra commentary from Mr. Kahn:
- FAH: STILL ROOM FOR IMPROVEMENT ON PAY FOR PERFORMANCE —
- “…. The study found that hospitals made progress in improving patient care, as evidenced by a 10 percent drop in hospital readmission rates. However, it said that there is still work to be done on how the programs are designed to avoid overlap in penalties.
- Kahn’s study found that some hospitals were getting dinged by all three programs based on performance on the same measure that was applied either directly or indirectly under each program. The study found that under the Hospital Value-Based Purchasing Program, about 45 percent of an estimated 3,000 hospitals were penalized. About 75 percent of hospitals were penalized through the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program. And under the Hospital-Acquired Condition Reduction Program, teaching hospitals were disproportionately penalized, with 56.6 percent of those facilities facing penalties.
- ‘Hospital quality has improved for seniors with the advent of new value-based programs tied to payment. But, the findings of our research indicate that we can do better,” Kahn told PULSE. “Mid-course corrections are necessary to focus policies on what really matters for care and to avoid redundancy and ensure relevance of metrics.’”
The study and one of its primary charts were spotlighted in Morning Consult’s Health Brief:
- Today’s Chart Review
- Assessing Medicare’s Hospital Pay-For-Performance Programs And Whether They Are Achieving Their Goals
- from Health Affairs by Charles N. Kahn III, Thomas Ault, etc.
Bloomberg BNA included a brief synopsis of the study in its Health Care Daily Report:
- Report: Medicare Quality Efforts to Have Broad Impact on Hospitals’ Pay
- Posted August 04, 2015, 3:06 P.M. ET
- By Michael D. Williamson
- Most hospitals will see a payment reduction under at least one of Medicare’s quality payment programs, a report found.
- The report, published in the August issue of the journal Health Affairs, examined Medicare’s programs on hospital readmissions reduction, value-based purchasing and hospital-acquired condition reduction. Four out of five hospitals subject to the programs will be penalized under one or more of them in 2015, the report found.
- The report’s authors said that a growing share (6 percent by 2017) of Medicare hospital payments will be dependent upon how hospitals perform under the three programs. Charles Kahn III, the president and chief executive officer of industry group Federation of American Hospitals, served at the lead author.
Bloomberg BNA also reported on the study in a full piece:
- “A consultant who didn’t author the Health Affairs report said the findings show the quality programs are working.
- Andrew Agwunobi, a managing director at Berkeley Research Group, told Bloomberg BNA Aug. 4 the report offers two important takeaways.
- First, it shows that Medicare’s quality programs are working and there are improvements in the metrics the initiatives are measuring, Agwunobi, a former hospital executive, said. However, he disagreed with the report’s suggestion that public reporting alone—rather than imposing pay reductions—could have achieved similar results. Part of the problem with relying on public reporting for improving quality is that consumers aren’t good at interpreting hospital quality reports, Agwunobi said.”
Modern Healthcare included the new study published by Health Affairs in “Medicare readmission penalties create quality metrics stress”:
- “Although the reimbursement blow to most hospitals next year will be less than 0.5%, the cumulative impact of Medicare’s quality programs is piling up. Certain facilities, such as major teaching hospitals, are disproportionately affected, according to a recent article in the journal Health Affairs, co-authored by Federation of American Hospitals CEO Chip Kahn.”
FierceHealthFinance highlighted the study’s analysis of financial incentives in the pay-for-performance programs examined:
- “In the article, Kahn praised some of the quality initiatives that have been developed under the ACA, particularly the Hospital Readmissions Reduction Program, the Value-Based Purchasing (VBP) Program, and the Hospital-Acquired Condition (HAC) Reduction Program. But he also pointed out significant flaws, which included the “redundancy and relevance of measures that are used in both the VBP and HAC programs; the arbitrary, musical chairs-like HAC penalty that punishes a quarter of all hospitals every year regardless of how well those institutions have improved, or even potentially of how well they actually performed; and, the silence of the readmissions measure on the critical socio-economic factors, which studies show are likely to influence readmissions of low-income patients for reasons beyond the hospital’s capacity to affect.””
Healthcare Finance reported on the study’s in-depth analysis:
- “In the Health Affairs study, Khan and the Health Policy Alternatives set out to asses the three hospital pay-for-performance programs and whether they are achieving the goals outlined in the ACA. To at least some effect, they are.”
The Health Affairs blog published a commentary by Mr. Kahn in tandem with the study’s publication, which offers further insight on hospital quality initiatives and the history of this effort in the U.S.
- “It is clear we have work to do to improve quality and performance measurement in these Medicare programs. It is imperative that we get these revisions right. At the same time, we must also pursue improvements to those Medicare and Medicaid initiatives that use these measures to support value-based payment.”
The FAH is pleased to receive recognition for the study, and welcomes further exploration and discussion on the issue of hospital & health care quality.
