A study released last week by the Journal of the American Medicaid Association (JAMA) provides in-depth analysis of the Hospital-Acquired Condition (HAC) Reduction Program, with findings that echo those from an FAH authored Heath Affairs study released Monday. The two studies share many common threads and a key similar conclusion: these programs have yielded successes and demonstrated some shortcomings that must be addressed so that the programs can evolve and work effectively.
The JAMA study focuses on the Hospital-Acquired Conditions (HAC) Reduction Program instituted by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) in 2015. In analyzing the characteristics of hospitals penalized under the program, the study frames its findings as “paradoxical.” and pointing the way to a restructuring of the HAC Reduction Program.
“Among hospitals participating in the HAC Reduction Program, hospitals that were penalized more frequently had more quality accreditations, offered advanced services, were major teaching institutions, and had better performance on other process and outcome measures. These paradoxical findings suggest that the approach for assessing hospital penalties in the HAC Reduction Program merits reconsideration to ensure it is achieving the intended goals.”
As part of the Health Affairs study, Assessing Medicare’s Hospital Pay-for-Performance Programs and Whether They Are Achieving Their Goals, author Chip Kahn, the President and CEO of FAH, also analyzed the Hospital-Acquired Conditions (HAC) Program along with two other pay-for-performance programs, the Hospital Readmissions Reductions Program and the Value Based Purchasing Program, or (VBP).
In reaching the shared conclusion that the HAC program requires revision, both studies outlined a strong difference between the intended purpose of the HAC Reduction program and the skewed results following implementation. Also notable, both studies found teaching hospitals were disproportionately impacted, receiving significantly more penalties than other hospitals.
Mr. Kahn notes in an op-ed published Tuesday on the Health Affairs blog:
“Effective and relevant measurement is critical to the effort to improve hospital care. It is important now to focus on the current form of metrics for corrective action. A roadmap for policymakers and researchers alike to redirect our performance evaluation is provided by the latest report on quality from the IOM. The “Vital Signs” report recommends a set of “core metrics” (including measures such as life expectancy, patient safety, and healthy communities), which will provide an infrastructure that can be used to concentrate assessment on what is truly most essential for health care delivery.
Beyond adopting the principles in “Vital Signs,” over time, hopefully, performance measurement will evolve with use of “big data” that, when accessed and analyzed, will enable more effective, efficient, and timely use of measurement and will offer better support care for decisions.”
The FAH is committed to lasting quality improvement programs. However, as regulations evolve, innovation transforms technologies, and the delivery of health care evolves, these quality payment programs must be reviewed and adapted to ensure hospitals are evaluated accurately, paid effectively, and patients are able to find and receive the best care possible.