A recent New York Times article asks important questions surrounding the slew of potential insurance company mergers among the nation’s largest health insurance providers. Last week, Aetna announced its acquisition of smaller competitor Humana, and Centene revealed its plan to buy Health Net. Across the industry, the five largest insurers are seeking to consolidate, with the expectation that the 5 will merge into just 3 mega-corporations.
The article poses a series of questions posited by consumers and industry experts alike:
As insurers grow larger, will consumers benefit from the companies’ ability to bargain with hospitals and doctors for lower prices? Will diminishing competition translate to fewer choices of plans? And what effect will mergers have on innovation in health care?
As shown in the diagram below, insurers have enormous power at the state level, controlling a large portion of the market. The article explains that this drive to merge is steeped in part for insurers to gain more market power, which leaves consumers uneasy about their benefits options.
“One primary reason for the latest merger mania is the companies’ need to have more clout in more local markets so they can negotiate better deals with local hospitals and doctors…. But consumer advocates are skeptical that more consolidation is the answer. “In most markets, insurers are pretty consolidated already,” said Claire McAndrew, who follows the private insurance market for Families USA, a consumer advocacy group in Washington. “I’m not sure if further consolidation is going to have a further impact.”’
Increasing insurer consolidation in the states is nothing new; in fact, there is a years-long trend of one or two insurers claiming the majority of local insurance markets. The American Medical Association been analyzing the concentration of market power among insurers for the last few years. In its 2014 annual report Competition in Health Insurance – A Comprehensive Study of U.S. Markets the AMA found that only 2 insurers controlled 50% or more of the market in 47 of the 50 U.S. states.
Greater market power for insurers impacts insurance benefit plan design, in which greater risk and cost-sharing responsibilities are shifted onto the consumer. Today, consumers are experiencing higher out-of-pocket costs and growing premiums with the growing number of more high-deductible plans from their insurers. This paradigm shift in benefit design will only be made more severe with these potential mergers currently on the table.
The article goes onto explain how mergers (and subsequently disproportionate market power in the hands of one party in the health care system) impact negotiations among benefit providers and care providers.
“The urge to merge may also signal less willingness by the big insurers to create new plans and to work with hospitals and doctors on novel ways of delivering care.
‘”This is just going to undercut any motivation for innovation,” said Rob Fuller, a former hospital executive who is now a lawyer at Nelson Hardiman in Los Angeles. He predicts that the big insurers will use their newly found clout to return to the time when all that mattered was trying to obtain lower prices rather than rethinking their relationships with the providers. “It’s going to be back to blunt force, take it or leave it,” he said.”’
The questions being posited across the industry, and the red flags raised by consumer advocates are an important check on the health care system. Studies like the one by the AMA show us the results of rampant insurer consolidation on patients and local communities. Combined with the feedback from consumers on their mounting health care costs and diminishing plan options, there is rightful cause for concern about mega-deals among the national private insurance behemoths.