Don’t Believe the Hype: The Realities of Protecting Patient Access

In a recent CQ Healthbeat article, Associate Editor Rebecca Adams highlighted the ongoing controversy the insurance industry has attempted to create regarding hospital consolidation.  Insurers have resumed their allegations about hospital integration in the midst of the new health insurance exchanges opening nationwide.  With exchange enrollment now open, their diversionary tactics have taken on new energy, in the hope consumers and the media will not pay attention to the premium rate shock, limited provider networks and restrictive benefits many will find as they explore insurance company exchange offerings.  In her article, Adams writes:

“Chip Kahn, President and CEO of the Federation of American Hospitals, took exception to a comment by America’s Health Insurance Plans President and CEO Karen Ignagni…. In an interview with reporters after she addressed an industry conference, Ignagni called hospital consolidation “dangerous,” adding, “I say dangerous because it affects the prices that are being charged and it makes it very difficult to negotiate affordable premiums.”

Ignagni also invited scrutiny of hospital prices by saying, “The focus so far has been on the premiums charged in exchanges but premiums are based on the underlying cost of hospital care, pharmaceuticals and other services.”

In an interview with Adams, I told her I was “taken aback” by Ignagni’s choice of words, adding,

“The insurance industry seems to be on this jihad regarding hospital consolidation.” “It’s the proverbial pot calling the kettle black. There is a lot of concentration in that industry.”

It is disappointing to see insurers continuing to play this blame game, going out of their way to tout outdated analyses that are often rooted in flawed data.  Insurers are attempting to play it both ways—lambasting hospitals for realignments (in the form of hospital mergers and acquisitions) that are undertaken to ensure patient access and build better, more coordinated care delivery systems—while they are not shy about increasing consumer premiums, instituting larger out-of-pocket cost sharing responsibility and implementing complicated deductible policies.

Rather than get into a war of words with insurers, hospitals choose to let the facts about ensuring patient access represent the reality of hospital integration:

  • * The U.S. is in the middle of an historic spending slowdown trend in health care that is impacting public policy in real-time.  Study after study, and several critical government data points corroborate this trend.  This slowdown amounts to real savings both in Medicare and in helping reduce the federal deficit by trillions of dollars.
  • * This critical trend is largely driven by structural changes in health care that have been implemented over a span of time.  These changes—which include investment in health IT, workforce development and growth of integrated care systems—have all been put in place to drive greater quality, efficiency and coordination across the U.S. health care system.
  • * In roughly the same time period that hospitals were working to implement systemic change, average insurance premiums have increased, more than doubling trend growth in health care spending.
  • * The most recent AMA study that analyzes competition in the health care marketplace found that 90% of markets in the U.S. had highly concentrated health insurance.
  • * At the same time, hospitals face nearly half a trillion dollars in Medicare and Medicaid payment cuts over the next ten years.  More than $95 billion in payment cuts have been enacted in the last three years alone.  These cuts directly impact patients’ access to care and serve as a factor driving hospital integration.

Our partner, The American Hospital Association, echoed many of these points in the CQ piece:

“It is not hospital prices that are driving the rise in insurance premiums,” AHA spokesperson Alicia Mitchell said in an email. “Hospital price growth is at the lowest in more than a decade. Hospitals are responding to private sector and government policies to provide more coordinated and efficient health care by, among other strategies, partnering with others. Sometimes these partnerships involve mergers and acquisitions, which are subject to strong oversight at the federal and state level.”

At the end of the day, it is a combination of policy goals, new legislation, public payer incentives and cuts to hospital payment – approaching nearly half a trillion dollars over the next ten years – driving hospitals to think more about integrated care.  The ultimate priority for hospitals is protecting patients’ access to care. Hospitals are working to break down the siloed models of the past and design new care delivery strategies that focus on a more coordinated experience for patients.  This trend is just beginning, but many believe it has staying power.

As insurers cling to what I believe is an “audacity of hype” – sustaining a drum beat against hospital consolidation in order to divert attention away from the reality of higher out-of-pocket costs and less choice for consumers – hospitals will continue to stand by the facts, sound data and goals of creating accessible, quality care for all patients.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>