Today, the FAH joined the American Hospital Association in filing an amici curiae brief in the U.S. Supreme Court Case Tibbs v. Bunnell. The case centers on a critical issue affecting patient safety organizations today, namely the ability to safeguard patient safety information reports prepared by health systems so that organizations can learn from errors and proffer best practices and protocols for the entire industry. To best understand the amici brief, it is best to look at the history behind patient safety organizations.
When Congress passed the Patient Safety and Quality Improvement Act in 2005, its goal was to encourage health care providers to join or create new patient safety organizations that would collect information on reported errors from providers, analyze their causes and advise ways to avoid them in the future. The model of analysis was based on other fields in which Congress has added error reporting structures.
Prior to this law, providers generally were reticent to report errors or join groups to help educate the industry and improve patient care. Much of this aversion stems from providers’ concern about making the report information public.
As described in the brief:
“Congress understood that providers would not report to patient safety organizations unless they were confident that their reports would remain privileged. It therefore built into the Patient Safety Act a promise of nearly absolute confidentiality for reports to patient safety organizations: the reports could not be used in any forum—state or federal, civil or criminal— assuring providers that they could honestly assess their mistakes without fear of repercussions. Congress, then, explicitly linked the Patient Safety Act’s success to courts’ enforcement of the Act’s privilege for reports to patient safety organizations. If providers cannot rely on the privilege, patient safety organizations cannot achieve the Act’s goals for them.”
The Tibbs v. Bunnell case centers on a ruling in Kentucky which effectively nullifies the federal privacy guarantees. The Kentucky Supreme Court decided Tibbs v. Bunnell in a way that compromises the effectiveness of the Act. Under the decision, trial court judges will have greater discretion to release patient safety report information to a tort plaintiff. Providers will have no choice or guidance as to what different judges will or will not release, leaving them particularly vulnerable, especially in medical liability litigation.
As argued in the brief:
“The Kentucky Supreme Court’s decision is particularly unwarranted because it is unnecessary to assure negligent providers are held accountable for careless and avoidable mistakes. Plaintiffs still have access to their medical records, and they may use the traditional tools of discovery to find out the facts underlying an incident. All plaintiffs cannot do under the federal Patient Safety Act is obtain the reports providers make to patient safety organizations. The Kentucky Supreme Court may not like that limitation, but that is the balance Congress struck, and it was a choice for Congress, not the courts, to make.”
The use of privileged health care information is essential to enable patient safety organizations to make health care facilities safer and raise the bar of quality of patient care. The FAH stands fully behind the Patient Safety and Quality Improvement Act, which is designed to protect patient safety information that allows for improved care and outcomes.