FAH President and CEO Charles N. Kahn III assesses the status of the HITECH Act and the state of electronic health record (EHR) implementation and health information exchange more than 5 years since the legislation’s passing in a comprehensive commentary published in this week’s Modern Healthcare magazine.
The adoption and implementation of EHRs have been a major priority for the health care community since the passage of the HITECH Act, and President Obama’s 5-year computerization pledge in 2009. While the HITECH Act, through the EHR Incentive Programs, has been extremely successful in driving uptake of EHRs, other national priorities addressed and funded in the law, including interoperability, have lagged. As Kahn explains:
“The law envisioned building a nationwide interoperable information superhighway, ensuring patient information gets to the right place at the right time to enable better decisionmaking at the point of care.”
In the past five and a half years, hundreds of millions of dollars have been spent attempting to build health information exchange infrastructure and capabilities across the country. Despite this significant financial investment, Kahn points to a glaring lack of macro-interoperability between health care providers as a missed opportunity by both the public and private sectors. Kahn explains:
“The problem is the failure to achieve “macro” interoperability – the movement of patient information outside the walls of a facility. Macro-interoperability is happening in pockets of the country, but certainly not on the scale Congress envisioned when it passed the HITECH.
The law’s initial vision was dependent on three factors: technology, aligned incentives and a culture that enables information to flow. Yet instead of enabling these factors to flourish, we allowed them to atrophy, due largely to what ultimately is a cultural problem – a fundamental distrust of external information among providers and clinicians – that supersedes any policy lever the law created.”
Another missed opportunity, Kahn says, is the lack of focus on the “micro” interoperability problem occurring within health care facilities; this prevents EHRs from working efficiently with other technologies that collect important patient data and departments from communicating with one another effectively.
“Further, meaningful use’s myopic focus on EHRs means that national-level discussions about interoperability effectively ignore the multitude of medical technologies within a facility that generate critical patient data, including devices, modules and other digital instruments. When you ask hospital chief information officers what matters to them, they talk about these technologies and their lack of plug-and-play connectivity with EHRs, even though this problem of “micro-interoperability” continues to be omitted from the growing number of frameworks and roadmaps focusing on how to achieve a connected healthcare system.”
“It is sobering to realize that hundreds of millions of dollars were spent experimenting on how to get patient X’s information from Ohio to Florida, yet we cannot convey data from a digital blood pressure cuff into an EHR three feet away without some type of work-around.”
Kahn concludes his retrospective analysis of the national health IT efforts with a look ahead for health care providers.
“HITECH’s stated goals in 2009 of reducing errors, bringing down costs, ensuring privacy, and saving lives are still the right goals for patients, providers and the healthcare system as a whole. Yet, absent interoperability, macro or micro, their prospects seem shaky at best.
As we look to the future – to Stage 3 meaningful use and eventually a post-HITECH world, it is critically important to continue striving to realize the law’s larger vision for health information technology. At the same time, one “lesson learned” should be never to underestimate the value of taking a concrete step, such as moving information from a digital blood pressure cuff into an EHR a few feet away.”
The FAH has long supported the goals of the HITECH Act. Investments in health IT are one of the pillars of structural changes that are key in the transformation of the American health care system. Hospitals will continue our efforts to achieve improved interoperability on all levels necessary to realize the full potential of health IT to improve the quality, safety and efficiency of health care for patients.