Hospital Realignment: Real Benefits to Communities, Patient Access to Care Protected

Over the course of recent weeks, we have seen a growing trend in press coverage of hospital realignment.  More and more, reporting has highlighted cases of contemporary mergers, outlining significant benefits to patients and communities as well as robust competition in local markets where these transactions are taking place.  Fresh metrics tied to 21st century hospital realignment are providing the clearest, most accurate picture of the impact on the health care industry.

And that picture provides quite the juxtaposition to the common misconceptions perpetuated since the 1990s.  Reliance on twenty-year old data and reference to a U.S. economy from that era has proven to be a poor means to understand what hospital realignment means today.

A report published earlier this year by FTI’s Center for Health Care Economics and Policy provided the most comprehensive meta-analysis of the most recent research about hospital realignments to date, helping to set the foundation for understanding market realities today.  The report outlined three key conclusions:

  1. There is no consistent statistical relationship between hospital realignment and price increases.
  2. Mergers and realignments offer significant and critical community benefits in the markets where these transactions occur.
  3. Realignments create more competitive health care markets.

Realignments help ensure hospitals stay open, thus protecting patient access to care.  More importantly, in many cases there is an expansion in services to communities that faced a potential hospital closure.  At a recent event featuring several health care experts involved in realignments from all sides of the industry, one hospital executive said, “I have seen clear benefits to our community and patients.  And we have seen operational efficiencies and lower costs. What we have seen of the past is one thing; what we see in the future is another thing. The types of things we can now do is game changing.”

There is one area of health care realignment where the game has not changed: health insurance consolidation.  For multiple consecutive years, a study by the American Medical Association has shown increasing insurer concentration in the market and markedly decreased competition. Included in the 2014 edition of the annual study is this staggering statistic:

  • 1 or 2 insurance companies control more than half of the market in 47 of the 50 states.

Insurers’ monopoly power means insurers can raise customer premiums and lower provider payments more freely, all at the expense of patient care.

As the adage goes: some things change, some things stay the same.  When it comes to hospital realignment, it is clear the trends have shifted, for the better for our patients and the communities we serve.  Unfortunately, insurance companies continue to pursue the same actions, growing their power and profit margins to the detriment of consumers.

With more and more data from contemporary mergers published, this new understanding of hospital realignment will continue to grow and the misconceptions will be resigned to history.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>