Hospital Realignments: Understanding Consolidation in the 21st Century

This morning, Politico Pro Health will convene a panel to discuss hospital realignments.  The event, “Consolidating Care” will serve as an in-depth discussion of the impact of efforts by hospitals to merge, realign and expand their systems to incorporate more health care providers in their region.

Though it is important to always be assessing the outcomes of these business transactions among hospitals – and their effect on the communities they serve —  there are a few important reminders the FAH hopes the panelists are mindful of in a substantive conversation such as this.

  1.        To understand effects, you must first look at the causes.

In assessing the current market for hospital realignment, understanding what is occurring in the health care industry at large is critically important.  This is a time of transformation for health care in the U.S.  We are seeing a transition to models of coordinated care, accomplished through integrated health care systems.  As our entire industry makes this shift, hospitals are struggling to absorb nearly $122 billion in cuts over ten years, imposed since 2010, while Medicare hospital payments have fallen eight percent below the cost of care in 2014 – an all-time low.

Fiscal sustainability and an evolving system are driving the pursuit of realignment.  Hospitals are merging and joining together to survive and thrive in this changing landscape.

    2.       Realignment today is not the same as the 1990s.

Earlier this year, the FAH commissioned the most comprehensive analysis of current hospital realignment.  The report by FTI’s Center for Healthcare Economics and Policy surveyed 75 studies of contemporary realignment to provide a meta-analysis of the impact on a national scale.

The report had many key conclusions on the effect of hospital realignments, several of which ran contrary to expert claims of price increases and monopolization of the market.  In their review, FTI found no consistent statistical relationship between realignment and price increases.

The report points to old data as the root cause for misconceptions on contemporary realignment.  Experts often cite examples or studies from 20 years ago, which is how these misconceptions perpetuate. These experts should not use studies or examples of realignment from the 1990s – or worse, compare today’s economy to that of the 90s – as a means to understand how these transactions work today.

    3.       Community benefits cannot be overlooked.

The biggest takeaway from the FTI analysis: in today’s economy, with today’s transforming health care model, hospital realignments yield a significant number of benefits to patients and the communities they serve.  We are seeing these benefits in real-time as realignments occur and their success reviewed in short order.

These mergers and acquisitions ensure hospitals stay open, and provide other important benefits, such as:

  • Preserved and expanded access to essential medical care
  • Improved service offerings and quality of care
  • Sustained and necessary investment in technology, facilities and health IT
  • Sensible reduction in excess capacity
  • More competitive health care markets

To borrow a phrase, this is not your mother’s consolidation.  Hospital realignments in the 21st century are yielding important improvements in care for patients, while allowing providers around the country the opportunity to stay open and modernize and expand their services.  The FAH looks forward to this morning’s discussion at the Politico Pro Health breakfast, and encourages the panel to utilize all of the most recent information on contemporary realignment in assessing this topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>