Insurers Expected to Increase Consolidation, Pursue More Mergers in 2015

A recent article in Modern Healthcare forecasts increasing merger and acquisitions activity among insurance companies in 2015, underscoring a disconcerting trend in health care: increasing insurer consolidation in markets across the country.  According to the article, insurers sought to merge before the implementation of ACA; and now, with the law in its second year, experts anticipate an uptick in the number of major M&As occurring among insurers.

  • “The last major wave came in 2011 and 2012…. Insurers completed those deals as the healthcare reform law’s minimum medical-loss ratios, federal reviews of rate increases, Medicare Advantage rate cuts and the health insurance premium tax were starting to take effect.  Transactions largely abated in 2013 and 2014 as insurers waited to see how the law would play out, said Chris Rigg, an analyst at Susquehanna Financial Group. Deals that occur were smaller, such as Blue Shield of California’s purchase of Care1st Health Plan. That watch-and-wait period could now be over.”

Though merger transactions have waxed and waned year on year, insurer consolidation consistently has been on the rise, as data from the annual AMA study show. Last October, a study by the American Medical Association found an increased concentration of insurance companies for the third year in a row, including an increase in market share even from the same study’s previous year:

  • -In 47 states, one or two insurance companies controlled 50% or more of the market share
  • -In 17 states, a single insurance company controlled 50% or more of the market share
  • -72% of metropolitan areas studied are rated “highly concentrated”
  • -90% of metropolitan areas studied had one insurer with 30% or more of the market share

Insurers continue to exercise anti-competitive market power across the country, driving competition out of the market. And through their increased power, health insurers are able to control coverage and benefits, which impacts providers and most importantly, consumers.

This problem affects patients and their access to care – a top priority for hospitals and providers across the country. As insurers benefit from their increasing dominance in the health insurance market today, patients only see premium increases and diminished coverage options.

New M&A deals in the new year will increase an already troubling trend that only serves to benefit insurance companies.

AMA Insurer Concentration Infographic

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>