The U.S. Senate Committee on Finance held a hearing on June 18, 2013, addressing health care price transparency. We were surprised at those who advocated at the hearing that the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA) does not advance meaningful health care transparency. In fact, the opposite is true. The ACA has strong and extensive provisions to promote transparency and ensure that consumers receive from health care insurers relevant, up-to-date and useful information about what they will pay for coverage, including out-of-pocket costs. Effective transparency is critical so that consumers can meaningfully compare health insurance options and make smart coverage and medical treatment choices.
For example, the ACA requires health insurers to provide enrollees and applicants with a uniform summary of benefits and coverage (SBC) so that consumers can compare health care coverage, including cost-sharing, limits, exceptions, reductions and coverage. The SBC must be written in plain language and contain no fine print, and must include examples to illustrate common benefit scenarios, including pregnancy and serious or chronic medical conditions and related cost-sharing. Notably, the ACA provides the Secretary of HHS with broad authority to implement these provisions and require insurers to provide consumers with the information they need to compare health insurance options.
Further, the law requires all health insurers to provide certain information to help consumers understand how reliably the insurer reimburses claims for covered services, a plan’s network adequacy, and other practical information, such as the number of claims denied, payment policies and practices, rating practices, cost-sharing and payment for out-of-network coverage, enrollee rights, and other important information.
And probably the most useful, the ACA provides that Exchanges, upon request of an individual, must require qualified health plans to give consumers cost-sharing information for specific items and services in a timely manner through at least an Internet website and otherwise for those without access to the Internet.
These provisions are sound public policies that are steps in the right direction. HHS has begun implementation, yet more needs to be done.
We encourage HHS to expedite implementation of these provisions to their fullest extent to ensure maximum transparency so that consumers have timely access to the information they need to compare the cost of health insurance plans and medical services prior to enrollment in a plan, including specific estimates of costs across an episode of care in which multiple providers may bill the patient separately. The health insurer is in the best position to provide this information and facilitate consumer “one-stop” shopping. Once enrolled, consumers should have up-to-the-minute access to out-of-pocket cost-sharing information to help make their medical treatment choices. This is the information that will drive marketplace competition and greater efficiency in health care delivery, and the ACA gives HHS the proper legal authority it needs to carry out this mission.