The public debate on the direction that health care spending is headed in the United States recently has been fueled by estimates of a sharp uptick in spending beginning in the 4th quarter of 2013. The predicted uptick, when taken out of context of the four years of historically low growth rates in national health care spending, predictably inspired doom and gloom amongst some in the health care space. However, new numbers from the Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA) turn these preliminary estimates and the corresponding “Chicken Little” predictions on their heads.
The BEA said Wednesday that spending actually dropped by an annual rate of 1.4% in the first quarter of 2014 – a complete about-face from earlier estimates. This extreme level of downward adjustment came as a surprise even to those who were skeptical of the estimated jump. Sarah Wheaton of POLITICO PRO reports that the year-over-year decrease in health care spending over the past five years could be the “new normal.”
Wheaton, in her piece, offers the following quote from Peter Orszag, former Director of the White House Office of Management and Budget during President Barack Obama’s first term:
“There’s a sea change going on that is causing health costs to grow much more slowly than they have historically.”
After a succession of CBO adjustments further and further reducing Medicare spending estimates over the past six straight years, the downward trend in spending points to structural changes in the way health care is delivered in our country. Wheaton adds:
“The new numbers do appear to lend ammunition to one side in the ongoing debate over what’s most responsible — the Great Recession or structural changes in how health care providers do business. Typically cited are the spread of accountable care organizations, the trend away from fee-for-service payments, the digitization of health care and employers’ moves toward defined-benefit insurance plans.”
It is becoming increasingly evident that the changes in health care delivery are driving the sustained spending slowdown – a slowdown that could yield as much as $900 billion in additional Medicare savings over the next decade, according to a recent study, commissioned by the FAH from the economic consulting firm Dobson | DaVanzo. The continued downward trend in health care spending from the BEA yesterday further supports the Dobson | DaVanzo study’s estimates of continued savings.
Clearly, a dynamic transformation is taking place, and hospitals are leading the way, from historically low price growth to clinically integrated care. Let’s not disrupt it with misguided policies or perpetual cuts to hospital funding.