Self-Referral to Physician-Owned Hospitals: U.S. Chamber Once Again Strongly Urges Congress to Retain Current Law Protecting Businesses and Taxpayers

For well more than a decade, community hospitals, policymakers, the business community and governmental advisory bodies have grappled with overutilization and higher health care costs caused by self-referral to physician-owned hospitals.  Conflicts of interest are inherent in these arrangements, where physician-owners refer their patients to hospitals for treatment in which they have an ownership interest. Nearly four years ago, after years of hearings, studies and faced with mountains of data on the adverse impact of these arrangements, Congress effectively banned self-referral to physician-owned hospitals.  Unfortunately, there is now an effort to unwind the law which would harm patients, community hospitals and local businesses.  That is why the U.S. Chamber of Commerce recently weighed against such efforts.

To understand what is at stake for patients and businesses, one needs to understand the history of self-referral to physician-owned hospitals and the policies surrounding it.

Cherry-picking patients

There is abundant evidence that physician-owner referrals result in the “cherry picking” of patients; that is to say physician owners will hand pick highly insured patients for referral for more profitable procedures.  Additionally, according to CBO, MedPAC and independent researchers, self-referral has resulted in higher utilization of services (“index events”) and higher costs for the Medicare program.  The GAO, CMS and MedPAC also have found that physician-owned specialty hospitals were treating healthier patients with the same diagnosis, and MedPAC and GAO further found that these physician-owned hospitals were treating far fewer Medicaid patients.

The net result of these behaviors: patients requiring more costly and complex treatments, as well as uninsured, underinsured and indigent patients were left to be treated at competing full-service community hospitals. This has been especially damaging to full-service community hospitals by creating a destabilizing environment that threatens the foundation of community hospitals and their ability to continue to serve the needs of the community.

Diminished quality, emergencies & further strain on local hospitals

In 2008, the Department of Health and Human Services’ Office of the Inspector General (HHS OIG) issued a report regarding the ability of physician-owned specialty hospitals to respond to and manage medical emergencies.  The HHS OIG report found, in part, that “[t]wo-thirds of physician-owned specialty hospitals use 9-1-1 as part of their emergency response procedures,” and “[m]ost notably, 34 percent of [specialty] hospitals use 9-1-1 to obtain medical assistance to stabilize patients, a practice that may violate Medicare requirements.”

The data clearly show that self-referral created an unleveled, anti-competitive playing field and threatened patient safety, as well as the health care safety net provided by full-service community hospitals.

Legislative history

In 2003, due primarily to concerns of cherry picking and rapid growth in this sector originally raised by the GAO, the Medicare Modernization Act placed an 18-month ban on referrals to new physician-owned specialty hospitals.  In 2005, the Deficit Reduction Act extended through August 2006 an administrative suspension of admitting new physician-owned specialty hospitals into the Medicare program.  In 2010, with the support of the business and hospital communities, bipartisan legislation was enacted that prospectively banned physician-self referral.  Grandfathered arrangements also were required to provide a new level of financial and patient safety transparency.  Further, grandfathered arrangements were allowed to expand only if they meet certain conditions.

Since the enactment of this ban, the system has been working and continues to work.  The instability created by the proliferation of self-referral has calmed.  Patients can choose the appropriate facility for the procedures and treatments they need, health care spending is kept in check, and there now are instances where grandfathered arrangements, having met the law’s conditions, have been permitted to grow.

What’s at stake

Unfortunately, the business community and hospitals once again find themselves at a legislative crossroads.  Draft legislation is circulating in the House that would gravely weaken the ban on self-referral to physician-owned hospitals. Not only would the draft legislation provide a mechanism for new facilities to open, it would allow unfettered expansion for grandfathered hospitals.

This draft legislation has caught the attention of the business community, which is rightfully concerned about the implications of weakening current law.  In response, on November 21st, U.S. Chamber of Commerce sent a letter to Congressional leadership describing the devastating effects of self-referral to physician-owned hospitals.  The letter explains:

“Unbridled, spiraling health care costs is one of the most important challenges facing our health care system today. One legal protection that currently helps combat unnecessary cost increases is a safeguard against certain self-referral practices. When the most profitable patient cases are referred to hospitals where physicians have a financial interest, “cherry-picking” occurs. While this referral practice increases profits for these physician-owned hospitals, such cherry-picking also has the negative impact of leaving the more complicated and poorly reimbursed cases to be treated by neighboring community hospitals.”

“The Chamber urges Congress to not take a step backward on this policy which has historically enjoyed strong bipartisan support dating back over a decade. Although the Chamber and many lawmakers strongly opposed the Affordable Care Act (ACA) generally in 2010, the Chamber and many bipartisan lawmakers have for years supported the protections and safeguards codified in §6001 of the ACA. This provision is working by appropriately limiting the practice of self-referral to physician-owned hospitals, which increases utilization and costs to businesses and taxpayers, as well as distorting health care markets. The Chamber supports the current self-referral law and opposes any effort to unwind or weaken it.”

The FAH stands with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce in supporting the existing law on self-referral to physician-owned hospitals.  The FAH agrees with the Chamber that – “Balancing entrepreneurial spirit and sound public policy is no easy feat, but Congress achieved the right balance when it prohibited self-referral prospectively while grandfathering current arrangements…”

The law as it stands protects patients, businesses, and taxpayers.  It also helps ensure that full-service hospitals can continue to meet their mission to serve all the patients in their communities.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>