In their seemingly endless attempts to paint hospital realignment as a venture to increase costs, insurers continue to allege that system integration, mergers and other business transactions put them at a disadvantage in price negotiations. However, a report released this September shows the reality to be quite the opposite: trends show a majority of insurers retained market power and drove their own profit margins higher over an 8 year period at the sake of consumers through the Medical Loss Ratio or MLR.
To best explain MLR: when an insurer collects its premiums, it can do one of two things:
- * Retain that money for its own overhead costs and profits (commonly known as insurer administrative costs), or
- * Use the premium funds to pay claims such as medical care and quality improvements for its beneficiaries
When an insurance company’s MLR decreases, that means less money is being paid out to customer claims and more is being kept by the insurance company. An increasing MLR would mean more money is going out to cover claims, which would in turn create a vulnerability for insurers. Based on their allegations of hospital market power, insurers would lead us to believe their MLR has been trending upwards. The Center for Regulatory Effectiveness (CRE) shows this to be untrue in its report, “A Signature Study on Hospital Consolidation Violated the Data Quality Act.”
In the report, CRE assesses data from 2000-2008, a time period in which 7 of 10 insurance companies decreased their MLR, keeping more of the premium money for themselves. In fact, some of the decreases are significant, reporting a MLR decrease of as much as 11% in just 8 years.
What does this mean for consumers? The premiums you pay for your insurance—whether that is through your employer or on your own if you are self-insured—are there to cover your claims and medical costs. When insurers keep more of those premium dollars for their overhead and profits, consumers suffer.
Health insurers may claim they have little or no market power or leverage in negotiations with payment to hospitals and other health care providers. The data from the CRE report regarding MLR is the reality check on just how powerful insurance companies remain, focused on their own bottom line. Insurers could not decrease their MLRs for that long a period of time without significant leverage. And that power applies even more so to those who have decreased their MLR by over 10%.
Perhaps the ultimate sign of insurers crying wolf: the CRE report cites a Health Affairs article that outlines insurers’ reluctance to submit their MLR data to a 2010 Senate Commerce Committee investigation on MLRs. Congress was forced to bypass the insurers and obtain information from the National Association of Insurance Commissioners.
Under the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (ACA), Congress, wise to insurers’ real MLR data, enacted consumer protections that now require insurance companies to dedicate 80-85% of their premiums on medical care and quality improvement. What games will health insurance companies try next?
These insurance companies can continue to make false claims about their position in the health care industry, or try to hide the data from Congress but they cannot hide from reality. The market power and influence they wield is evident when you strip away the accusations and look at the facts.
Hospitals are not in the business of making accusations about others in the industry; we are in the business of caring for people and ensuring their access to quality health care is available 24/7. Hospitals’ mission will not change as insurers continue to wage a fruitless campaign to malign your local hospitals and protect their profits.
