Critical Terms and Facts: A Primer for the Upcoming Health Care Transparency Summit

This week, stakeholders from across the health care industry will gather in Washington, D.C. for the National Summit on Health Care Price, Cost and Quality Transparency, a three-day event that will host a variety of panels discussing the many facets of health care financing.  This meeting comes on the heels of news from the White House Council of Economic Advisers who recently released a report highlighting the historic spending slowdown trend in health care, largely attributed to structural changes in our industry.

Among the featured speakers at the summit is Steven Brill, author of “A Bitter Pill”, whose article in TIME magazine shed some light on the issues surrounding hospital financing, specifically the chargemaster.  Unfortunately, where Mr. Brill fell short was in providing full clarification about the realities of hospital financing.  Despite explaining the chargemaster, there was no complete breakdown of the difference between cost, charge and payment.  To put it simply:  words matter.  The chargemaster is one piece of a much larger reality for patients across the country who are receiving care at their local hospital.

The FAH reminds its colleagues and cohorts in health care who will be attending the conference, as well as the health care media covering the event, to remember these key issues as they participate in the summit:

  • * Protecting patient access is tantamount to everything.  In order to best care for patients, we must not lose sight of the ultimate priority that is true for both hospitals and for every single consumer: access to care.  Hospitals will never turn a patient in need of care away, ask for proof of coverage or ability to pay before we treat a patient.  Consumers should never have to question whether or not they can seek medical care; as such it is the responsibility of all facets of the health care industry to coordinate to preserve access for every single patient.
  • * Payments and costs are two entirely different items in hospital financing and health care financing as a whole.  (a full explanation of costs, charges and payments can be found here)
  • * The chargemaster is simply an internal hospital reference list of prices for thousands of items and services, required by CMS and sometimes used as a jumping off point for negotiations between hospitals and private insurers.
  • * The chargemaster pricing is not what government or patients pay.  Medicare pays hospitals a non-negotiable fixed price set by the federal government.  Patients who are covered by Medicare pay a small copayment amount that is also fixed by government.  Privately insured patients pay an amount whose terms are negotiated by their insurer.  What’s more, uninsured and underinsured Americans typically receive charity care or generous discounts from hospitals.  The bottom line:   the chargemaster is virtually a moot point when it comes to hospital payments.
  • * Transparency is necessary across ALL of the health care space.  The FAH has long supported the need for consumer-directed transparency in health care pricing.  Consumers are vested with the right to the information they need so that they can make educated decisions about their health care coverage.  In order for that to happen, all parties in the health care space must work to provide meaningful price transparency that promotes healthy consumer choice.  This is not something that any individual health care actor can opt into or out of.  We must all commit ourselves to the disclosure of actionable information for the sake of those for whom we are providing care and coverage.
  • * The critical importance of the spending slowdown and what it means for health care.  The never before seen trend of slowed health care spending has been reported on for the better part of 2013.  And the good news is this trend is strengthening amid increasing signals that its source is structural and enduring in nature, rather than tied to the receding recession. These changes underscore the overall transformation of the industry to, for example, a model of coordinated care to best provide for consumers and guarantee their access to quality care.  All parties in the health care sphere can agree this spending slowdown is proof positive of the investments we have made to improve care; it is imperative we all work to preserve this trend and prevent any policies that could hamper or altogether halt the slowdown.
  • * Hospital realignment enhances patient access and efficiencies, while averting hospital closures and reduced services.  Today’s rapidly changing health care landscape is driven largely by two elements: diminishing Medicare and Medicaid payments that already fall far below the cost of care, and demands for greater efficiency and higher quality of care.  Hospitals are doing their part through strategic realignment.  The benefits are clear and far-reaching, paramount among them: preserving access to local health care, 24/7.   Realignment enables hospitals to preserve access to care, improve quality of care and help bend cost curves much in the way we have seen them impacted by the spending slowdown.  Hospitals are under immense fiscal pressure, and the risk of closure and the damage that causes to communities is real.  Realignment is the pathway to economies of scale,  access to capital, operating efficiencies, and investments in the people and technology that improves population health.

The FAH welcomes responsible gatherings of the health care industry to discuss the most pressing issues and policies of the day.  We do ourselves and consumers a great disservice, however, when we do not discuss issues with full clarity.  Any conference or summit of the health care industry must ask the tough questions and focus on the realities of our work.  We cannot accomplish anything without a truthful, complete understanding of the world in which we all work.  We hope the summit delivers a product that provides such an understanding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>