In a study released December 1, the Government Accountability Office (GAO) revealed research showing significant, sustained concentration in the private health insurance market from 2010 to 2013, with concentration even increasing in many states. The market share numbers among insurers once again are staggering, proving continued concentration among just a handful of insurance companies.
The study examined three segments of each state’s health insurance markets: individual, small group and large group, finding,
“…in 2013, enrollment was concentrated among the three largest insurers in most states. Specifically, in each of the three market segments, the three largest insurers had at least 80 percent of the total enrollment in at least 37 states. Further, these three market segments remained concentrated in most states from 2010 through 2013. Specifically, for each of these market segments, there were at least 30 states for which the three largest insurers had at least 80 percent of the total enrollment in each of the 4 years.”
The GAO report reinforces a well-known and extremely disconcerting trend within the health insurance industry. In October, the American Medical Association released its annual report also examining the private health insurance market, which shows increased insurer consolidation for the last 3 consecutive years. The trends in the new GAO study are notably consistent with those found in the 2014 AMA release, which reported:
- In 47 states, one or two insurance companies control 50% or more of the market share.
- In 17 states, a single insurance company controls 50% or more of the market share.
Taken together, the two studies show how one to three large players dominate the markets in 37 of 50 states in this country. This is even further emphasized by the AMA’s finding that 72 percent of all metropolitan areas studied are highly concentrated.
The AMA and GAO reports, which are canvassing current trends and yearly data, provide consumers with a real-time understanding about the power insurance companies are amassing for their own benefit. Critics eager to distract from these reports are quick to assert hospital realignment as the alleged reason for higher health care costs, clinging to long-standing misconceptions of the impact of mergers among health systems on patients. However, it is imperative to point to the most recent reports on hospital realignment which outline new, positive trends—that of considerable community benefits, protected patient access to care and more competitive health care markets.
Further, hospital realignment, in part, is a reaction to the vast concentration of dominant market power held by health insurance companies across all major markets and market segments. Insurers undertook aggressive consolidation efforts starting in the 1990s, completely transforming the market and the way others in the industry interact with benefit providers. Hospitals, especially local community hospitals which keep their doors open to provide critical services for communities, struggle to attain reasonable provider payment terms because they are fighting massive market power among private health insurers—and have been for more than 20 years.
The trend makes one thing clear: increased insurer concentration is bad for consumers. Insurers’ increasing monopoly power sets the stage for higher premiums and out-of pocket-expenses for consumers as well as lower provider payments. Evidence of the growing anticompetitive forces in the health insurance market is striking, with data creating a frighteningly accurate picture of the current state of our health insurance coverage system and the market power insurers wield.
