Growing Commentary that Significant Structural Factors Are Driving the Spending Slowdown

We released our new analysis this morning Structural Changes Drive Health Care Spending Slowdown: Implications for Medicare Policy & Deficit Reduction, which synthesizes the macro trends demonstrating the historic slowdown in health care spending. Our analysis also, for the first time, puts all the most relevant academic research on what’s driving this spending slowdown in one place. Laurie McGinley, in her insightful Wonkblog post on the subject frames the issue perfectly.

It’s one of the hottest debates in health care: Is the historically slow growth in health spending in recent years due to the lingering effects of the recession, or is it a fundamental change that augurs well for the future? The implications are huge – if policymakers think the slowdown is only temporary, they might try to take steps to cut Medicare spending further, for example; if they think the improvement is permanent, they might cross their fingers and hope for the best.

Not only does our analysis by Dobson DaVanzo point to structural changes driving this macro trend, in accord with breakthrough work published in 2013 by David Cutler, professor of Applied Economics at Harvard and Nikhil Sahni, senior researcher in Harvard’s Economics Department – but a new independent study from PWC also released today corroborates this growing consensus.

The McGinley piece also references work done in April by the Kaiser Family Foundation and the Altarum Institute’s Center for Sustainable Health Spending. Larry Levitt, a researcher at the Kaiser Family Foundation who co-authored the April 2013 report had this to say about the Dobson DaVanzo findings:

“Over the last five decades, there has been a remarkably close relationship between the ups and downs in the economy and the ups and downs in health spending growth rates. The historic slowdown in health spending that we’re seeing now is consistent with that historical pattern, though there also appear to be significant structural factors at play as well.”

Our Dobson DaVanzo analysis agrees that “significant structural factors are at play” and finds that they are likely to have lasting effects that will not be eroded as the economy improves. The analysis points to several of these factors, including the ongoing implementation of the Affordable Care Act as well as quality care improvements like the reduction of hospital readmissions. Furthermore, the Dobson DaVanzo analysis also found that the data show there is not a clear relationship between health care spending growth and economic recessionary cycles, as depicted by the chart below using GDP growth as the primary economic indicator:

As the policy conversation regarding what’s driving the spending slowdown continues – the lesson for Congress is clear: We need to let recently enacted policy changes and reforms work before rushing in to another round of near-term Medicare cuts that would threaten patient access and could upend these historic trends of restrained health care spending.

 

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>