Last week, the Hartford Courant ran an Opinion Editorial by John Horak on the advantages of investor-owned (“for-profit”) hospitals. Horak is a Hartford attorney, who founded his firm’s Nonprofit Organizations Practice Area.
Investor-owned hospitals generally face the same market and regulatory conditions that non-profit hospitals do, but have met resistance as well as a few political and legislative roadblocks in Connecticut, halting efforts by investor-owned hospitals to partner with non-profit hospitals or otherwise assume ownership of and invest resources in a community hospital to keep it in top-notch condition. The reality is that investor-owned and non-profit hospitals are not all that different in their mission and structure, and both offer benefits to their communities.
The editorial explains that “for-profit and nonprofit hospitals must both operate profitably” and highlights the contributions that investor-owned hospitals add to their communities, the most important of which is to maintain access to high-quality health care and answer the call when public emergencies demand it.
“Our leaders should promote nonprofit/for-profit hospital conversions and affiliations because they are a prudent strategic lifeline for many of our hospitals and hospital systems… Communities with nonprofit hospitals gain value when a for-profits enters the market. State and federal laws say a for–profit must pay the fair market value of any nonprofit hospital it acquires — and that money must stay in the community in a locally managed “successor” charitable foundation for area health care needs.”
Facing similar operating conditions generally make non-profit and investor-owned hospitals nearly indistinguishable in the communities they serve. One distinction is that investor-owned hospitals typically have access to more varied sources of capital, for example equity financing, which enhances their ability to meet the health care needs of the communities they serve. In addition, investor-owned hospitals must also pay income and property taxes, providing desperately needed funding for a wide variety of local community functions such as education and transportation. Horak explains that “in many ways ‘tax-exempt’ and ‘taxable’ are the better terms to use to distinguish nonprofit from for-profit hospitals because both must earn a profit to survive.”
Finally, Horak outlines the core of every hospital’s mission, investor-owned or non-profit – their commitment to their patients who have grown to expect the highest standard of care from their providers:
“Hospitals operate between a rock and a hard place. The public expects excellent health care services regardless of the ability of people to pay. The cost of acquiring and maintaining facilities and the latest technology is enormous. Malpractice risk is a constant. State and federal regulations multiply exponentially, Medicare and Medicaid payments do not cover actual costs, and the economic dust of the Affordable Care Act is far from settled.”
Hospitals are open 24/7/365; during holidays, inclement weather and natural disasters. The obstacles faced by hospitals are already so great and the stakes so high that additional barriers to investor-owned arrangements or management are not just short-sighted – they are harmful to the communities served by those hospitals. The bottom line is, when a patient needs care, a hospital should be there to provide it, regardless of ownership.